Delhi HC says irretrievable breakdown of marriage not ground for divorce

The family court had granted the husband’s divorce petition on grounds of cruelty and desertion while dismissing the wife’s counterclaim for restitution of conjugal rights.

A division bench of Justices Sanjeev Sachdeva and Vikas Mahajan said that family courts must strictly adhere to the statutory provisions when considering divorce cases.

The court also referred to a recent Supreme Court ruling and clarified that the power to grant divorce on the grounds of irretrievable breakdown of marriage is vested in the Supreme Court under Article 142 of the Constitution to ensure justice to both parties.

The bench stated: “Family Courts have to restrict their considerations to the parameters of the provision of granting divorce strictly in accordance with the Act. Irretrievable breakdown of marriage is not a ground in the Act.”

The family court had observed that the marriage had broken down beyond repair due to the parties living separately for more than 11 years. However, the high court found errors in its decision.

The high court stated that the husband failed to prove the alleged cruelty, and divorce was granted solely on the basis of the denial of conjugal relations.

The court noted that such grounds were not available to the husband and that the allegations of denial of conjugal relations lacked specificity.

Furthermore, the high court said that the family court had only considered the prolonged separation of the parties as the basis for granting divorce, which was not within its jurisdiction.

The court noted that even the Supreme Court, when exercising discretionary powers under Article 142 of the Constitution, takes into account various factors, and the duration of separation is just one of them.

Hence, the high court ruled that the family court’s order granting divorce on the grounds of cruelty and the breakdown of marriage was not sustainable.